Matt Goddard
An incredible example of the power of the biopic
Adapted from the 2015 memoir of Marcelo Rubens Paiva, I’m Still Here (Ainda Estou Aqui ) is a film about family and politics. But it stands out thanks to its unconventional approach to biopic, transcending culture and language to make a notable splash on the international stage after riling the far-right in its home country.
It’s the early 1970s, and Brazil is under military dictatorship. Newly returned to Rio de Janeiro, the Peiva family, led by former congressman Rubens Peina (Selton Mello), attempts to ride out the crackdowns as their friends and allies start to flee.
The family is rocked when Rubens is taken in for questioning and never returns. With authoritarian rule tightening, Rubens’ wife, Eunice (Fernanda Torres), keeps her family of five children together as they forge a new future and refuse to bow to the authoritarian threat surrounding them.
I’m Still Here is packed with engaging performances. A naturalistic opening act brilliantly introduces us to the five children who are the film’s engine of hope and motivation. Then there are the parents, a warm and optimistic turn from Mello as Rubens and a display of extraordinary steel and strength from Torres as Eunice.
Torres is spectacular: a simmering stoic wick of calm awareness running through the film. Whether lightly questioning her friends, faced with terrifying interrogation, or floating alone in the Atlantic, her quiet shake of hidden rage and fear seals the film’s emotion.
That emotion is carefully built up as we’re invited into the Peiva house to spend time with her family. The mechanics of the political system, whether ruling or insurrectionary, are mostly kept to the periphery. For the first third, the military grip is only felt through a brutal police blockade at the start, then glimpses of a helicopter or a van of troops careering past while an important photograph is taken on the Rio beach.
Like his family, we’re not entirely clear what Rubens may have been up to. Aside from seeing the odd furtive envelope and courier, we only hear about his activities as Eunice does. Whatever her thoughts or suspicions about her husband aren’t the point, the injustice and cruelty of his disappearance are. After spending so much time with the family before Rubens disappears, time contracts during the hanging horror of his failure to return. Leaning heavily on the strength of the family unit as mapped out at the front of the movie and now led through almost unnavigable waters by Eunice is very effective.
It’s a daring and intelligent step for a biopic. I’m Still Here could have sunk into the dark interior of authoritarian rule as Torres and her daughter are detained. But it’s conveying that absence and uncertainty that’s important. Only the base strokes are needed to demonstrate Eunice’s return to academia and her family’s achievement after tragedy in the hands of the indomitable Torres and director Walter Salles.
The camera often hangs on the family members (particularly on Torres’ Eunice), but it also stunningly captures the Brazilian cityscapes that are both home and prison, safety and terror. Like the characters we’re invested in, the viewer is never quite sure where we are or what’s around us.
I can’t speak for Murilo Hauser and Heitor Lorega’s adaptation of Paiva’s memoir, but I can only believe it’s a masterful adaptation, given its rewarding structural choices. The result is a deftly epic film in terms of time, humanity and the stunning country of Brazil.
The Lowdown
Heart-wrenching but hopeful, I’m Still Here is an asymmetrical film that defies convention to keep the focus on the family at its heart. Compellingly off-kilter, it’s a master class in inviting an audience into a family and a country’s trauma while keeping us a crucial arm’s length of objectivity away.
Share this Review
Review by Matt Goddard
Your next read:
Sentimental Value — A Delicately Spun Web Of Family Meta
Sentimental Value is a beautiful journey through time and family, with all the sticky, dark, and horrible aspects of life along the way.
Joachim Trier spins a delicate spider’s web of meta and artistic catharsis behind some outstanding performances, and it’s all the better for handing these strong, memorable roles to three women.
Wuthering Heights — The Quickie And The Dead
If you’re going to crush the characters of a classic novel down, you may as well embrace the melodrama. Fennell crafts a stunning, unreal, wholly watchable romantic tragedy, recast as a dark fairy tale. It’s a memorable, sex-obsessed vision, even if it’s more blunt innuendo than erotic romp.
This adaptation isn’t interested in the haunting implications of Brontë’s work—the ghosts, metaphorical or literal, are severed with nihilistic glee. This Wuthering Heights is all about id—and that raging, impetuous, ill-thought-out lust unsurprisingly ends up being more about death than love. It may not be utterly shallow, but it’s selective. It may look stunning, but it’s a quickie.
Is This Thing On? — An Exquisite Re-falling In Love Film
Sterling stuff to re-line the heart: the re-falling in love film. Smartly developed from John Bishop’s biography, Arnett has unlocked a story that allows him to throw off some of his comedic baggage and shine as a not-so-comic comic. With Dern sparkling opposite him, the pair are simply a joy to watch.
While he delivers a bizarrely enjoyable cameo, it’s Cooper’s further development as a director that may be the film’s main legacy. His skill in drawing out the characters and balancing the sheer reality of the situation is remarkable and almost easy to miss. Is This Thing On? will likely prove to be a jewel in his glittering career. No pressure.
All images: © Sony Pictures Releasing
I'm Still Here
Release date: November 7, 2024 (Brazil)
Directed by: Walter Salles
Written by: Murilo Hauser, Heitor Lorega
Photographed by: Adrian Teijido
Edited by: Affonso Gonçalves
Score by: Warren Ellis
Starring: Fernanda Torres, Selton Mello, Fernanda Montenegro
Distributed by: Sony Pictures Releasing, StudioCanal
If you like this try...
Invisible Life (2019)
In the Heart of the World (2019)
Paloma (2022)
Recent Posts
The Secret Agent — A Brilliant Genre-Juggler
[dsm_social_share_buttons dsm_view="icon" dsm_shape="circle" dsm_button_size="1px" dsm_icon_size="18px" _builder_version="4.27.4" _module_preset="default" custom_css_main_element="display:inline-block;||float:right;"...
Sentimental Value — A Delicately Spun Web Of Family Meta
Wuthering Heights — The Quickie And The Dead
[dsm_social_share_buttons dsm_view="icon" dsm_shape="circle" dsm_button_size="1px" dsm_icon_size="18px" _builder_version="4.27.4" _module_preset="default" custom_css_main_element="display:inline-block;||float:right;"...
Is This Thing On? — An Exquisite Re-falling In Love Film
[dsm_social_share_buttons dsm_view="icon" dsm_shape="circle" dsm_button_size="1px" dsm_icon_size="18px" _builder_version="4.27.4" _module_preset="default" custom_css_main_element="display:inline-block;||float:right;"...
Hamnet — All The Stage’s Their World
[dsm_social_share_buttons dsm_view="icon" dsm_shape="circle" dsm_button_size="1px" dsm_icon_size="18px" _builder_version="4.27.4" _module_preset="default" custom_css_main_element="display:inline-block;||float:right;"...
Rental Family — A Dreamy Stroll Through White Lies
[dsm_social_share_buttons dsm_view="icon" dsm_shape="circle" dsm_button_size="1px" dsm_icon_size="18px" _builder_version="4.27.4" _module_preset="default" custom_css_main_element="display:inline-block;||float:right;"...
Kill Bill: The Whole Bloody Affair — Streamlined Revenge
[dsm_social_share_buttons dsm_view="icon" dsm_shape="circle" dsm_button_size="1px" dsm_icon_size="18px" _builder_version="4.27.4" _module_preset="default" custom_css_main_element="display:inline-block;||float:right;"...
Wicked for Good — Sticking The Landing
[dsm_social_share_buttons dsm_view="icon" dsm_shape="circle" dsm_button_size="1px" dsm_icon_size="18px" _builder_version="4.27.4" _module_preset="default" custom_css_main_element="display:inline-block;||float:right;"...
Frankenstein (London Film Festival 2025) — A Beautiful, Flawed Experiment
[dsm_social_share_buttons dsm_view="icon" dsm_shape="circle" dsm_button_size="1px" dsm_icon_size="18px" _builder_version="4.27.4" _module_preset="default" custom_css_main_element="display:inline-block;||float:right;"...


0 Comments